But, the menu offered good full dinner specials. We were in the mood for lighter fare and some drafts. Real BBQ'd meat has telltale definition from smoke penetration. Cozy spot with great food, good service and a friendly feel. I'd give it another try but I won't have high expectations. The waitstaff were very friendly as was the bartender who thanked us for coming as we left. /rebates/&.com252fRestaurantReview-g48552-d2628813-Reviews-or15-FiresideBBQGrill-SaltPointNewYork. This is a place that definately has the feel of a neighborhood place. As it turns out their menu shows a Red and a White Zin so I guess this was an issue of waitstaff not knowing their inventory. My husband enjoyed two local beers and I ordered a glass of Zin but was told they only had white Zin so I ordered a Pinot Noir instead. Mac and Cheese was uninspired and peanut slaw (which our waitress said is the only slaw she eats) was heavy on vinegar with raw peanuts added.

Pulled pork had a very sweet jarred variety sauce. Mashed potatoes had burned clumps throughout from obviously being scorched sitting in bainmarie. Fireside BBQ & Grill: Great local eatery - See 74 traveler reviews, 24 candid photos, and great deals for Salt Point, NY, at Tripadvisor. Fireside BBQ & Grill: The un-BBQ - See 74 traveler reviews, 24 candid photos, and great deals for Salt Point, NY, at Tripadvisor. Chicken skin looked crisp but was rubbery. I opted for the roasted half chicken with mashed potatoes and mixed veg. My husband And I started by sharing a Caesar salad. We were taken to the dining room and given a booth under a drafty air conditioner. Fireside BBQ & Grill: A Letdown - See 74 traveler reviews, 24 candid photos, and great deals for Salt Point, NY, at Tripadvisor. The game was on behind the bar which was full of people. Upon entering we were greeted warmly by waitstaff in football jerseys. After a day spent on a long country drive we swung off the Taconic to catch dinner. Fireside BBQ & Grill: Revisit reveals more problems at Fireside - See 74 traveler reviews, 24 candid photos, and great deals for Salt Point, NY, at Tripadvisor. Also had to listen to the 'chef' curse us because we gave our honest opinion when the waitress pressed us for our opinion and then relayed it back to him.I have been wanting to check this place out for awhile now. My fiance is from the South and we enjoy BBQ when we travel but this was definately not it.not even for NY. VERY disappointed!! The waitress was very kind and took off my meal without me asking but we will not be back and definately could not recommend. It was as if they had taken a piece of meat and dumped sauce on it before heating it in the oven. The beans were definately canned, the mashed potatos were a solid lump and the tri tip had no smoke ring, no bark and no flavor.

My fiance ordered the tri tip with mashed potatos and beans for his sides. The pulled pork appeared to have come out of a can.no smoke flavor and the most uniformly miniscule shreds I've ever had. The Mac and cheese side - pasta was never properly drained and it was more mac and cheese water. Fireside BBQ & Grill: I think they can do better - See 74 traveler reviews, 24 candid photos, and great deals for Salt Point, NY, at Tripadvisor. What can I say about the food? Well, the french fries were good. Placed our order and waited 40 minutes for our food while the other two tables (table of five plus a child and a table of six) were served.

First impression is a cozy little restaurant. Stopped in for late lunch and we (two of us) were the first of three tables seated.

Fireside bbq salt point ny menu